If your dog turns a new squeaky toy into confetti in ten minutes, you have a power chewer. The good news: a handful of toys are built for exactly that. The bad news: βindestructibleβ on a label means nothing. Here's what to look for, and the toys that hold up best.
What makes a chew toy safe and durable
- Size up. A toy should be too big to fit fully in your dog's mouth or slip down the throat.
- Not too hard. A common rule of thumb: if you can't press a fingernail into it at all, it may be hard enough to crack teeth. Very hard chews (bones, antlers, hard nylon) are best for supervised sessions.
- One solid piece. Avoid toys with glued-on parts, stuffing or squeakers for strong chewers.
- Replace when damaged. Once chunks start coming off, it's time for a new one.
- Best overall: KONG Extreme
- Best for fetch: Chuckit! Ultra Ball
- Best flavored chew: Benebone Wishbone
- Best tug toy: GoughNuts ring
KONG Extreme
The black KONG is the classic tough-dog toy for a reason: thick, bouncy natural rubber that gives a little under teeth. Stuff it with kibble, peanut butter (xylitol-free!) or wet food and freeze it to keep your dog busy for a long time.
- Rubber is firm but has some give
- Doubles as a food puzzle
- Comes in many sizes
- Determined chewers can still damage it β buy a size up
- Needs cleaning if you stuff it
Chuckit! Ultra Ball
A thick-walled rubber ball that bounces well, floats, and is bright enough to spot in grass. It's a fetch toy rather than a chew toy, so put it away after play.
- Floats β great for swimmers
- Works with Chuckit! launchers
- Easy to see
- Not meant for unsupervised chewing
- Pick the right size β small balls can be a choking risk
Benebone Wishbone
A nylon chew infused with real flavor (bacon, peanut, chicken). The wishbone shape lets dogs hold it between their paws, which many dogs love.
- Dogs find the flavor very motivating
- Shape is easy to grip
- Lasts a long time
- Hard β supervise, and skip it for puppies or dogs with dental issues
- Throw it away when it gets sharp or splintery
GoughNuts Ring
Made for strong chewers, with an indicator layer: if the inner colored layer shows through, it's time to replace it. A sensible safety feature.
- Built-in wear indicator
- Great for tug-of-war
- Made for heavy chewers
- Pricier than most toys
- Some dogs find it boring without a play partner
West Paw Zogoflex Hurley
A bendy, bone-shaped toy for dogs who like something with more give. It bounces, floats and is easy on gums.
- Softer on teeth than nylon
- Floats and bounces
- Dishwasher-safe
- Extreme chewers may still destroy it
- Fewer sizes than KONG
Toys to skip for power chewers
Plush toys, rope toys that shred into strings (swallowed fibers can cause blockages), tennis balls (the fuzz wears down teeth), and cooked bones (they splinter). When in doubt, supervise.